A new report from the Grattan Institute calls on the Federal Government to get together with Australia’s private health industry to urgently develop a rescue plan “to prevent it spiralling to its death”.
The report, Stopping the death spiral: creating a future for private health, calls for action on exorbitant out-of-pocket fees, private hospital costs, opaque arrangements in the prosthesis and device supply chain and unjustifiable premium increases.
“The industry was in a death spiral before the pandemic and it’s still in a death spiral today,” it says.
Co-author Dr Stephen Duckett, Health and Aged Care Program Director at the Grattan Institute, outlines its argument in the post below, cross published with permission from John Menadue’s Pearls and Irritations.
Stephen Duckett writes:
The future of private health in Australia – both private hospitals and private health insurance – is under challenge.
The proportion of the population with insurance has declined over the past decade. The insured population is getting older, which is putting upward pressure on insurance premiums, which leads to more people dropping out, especially younger people, creating a death spiral.
Statistics released by the insurance regulator last week confirm that trend continues.
Government responses so far has been a series of tweaks, a nip here, a tuck there. The latest was to allow stay-at-home adult children to remain covered by their family’s insurance policy until they turn 31.
The wishful thinking behind that idea is that the young adult will start paying for insurance then, to avoid the lifetime-cover penalties which increase premiums if you don’t take out insurance before turning 31.
It’s too early to tell whether this will work, but the incentives against young people taking out insurance — their expected use of healthcare services is low and the insurance premiums are high — apply equally at 30 as they did at 25, the age when the pyjama-clad stay-at-homes were previously kicked off the family policy.
Carrots and sticks
Private health is a big industry in Australia. More than half of all surgical procedures are performed in private hospitals, with almost all paid for by private health insurance. The sector employs thousands of people, and its future is important for the economy and for people’s continuing access to health care.
At the moment the private health insurance industry is propped up by complex array of carrots and sticks, most notably the private health insurance rebate which cost taxpayers about $6.4 billion this year, and tax penalties for middle and higher income Australians who are not insured.
Private procedures and other medical services in private hospitals are subsidised to the tune of a further $3 billion each year.
Despite these incentives, people are downsizing their membership, dropping to products which cover fewer procedures or have larger upfront payments if they use private health care. Fewer than one in eight of the insured population have ‘top cover’ – cover for everything with no excesses.
The private healthcare industry doesn’t help itself. Prices charged by device importers and manufacturers and by private hospitals for prostheses have been more than twice what the public sector pays – a rort still not addressed despite some tinkering in the recent federal Budget.
A handful of greedy doctors charge way above the Medicare benefit schedule. About 6 per cent of all medical services in private hospitals are billed at more than twice the schedule fee. Patients – after paying a lifetime of private health insurance premiums – end up with nasty bill shock.
Private hospitals are less efficient than public hospitals, with their patients staying in hospital longer on average. And the amount of premiums which get returned to contributors as benefits varies across funds – with some insurers holding back more than 15 per cent.
So where to from here? Is private health insurance to be the next automobile industry, with government saying enough is enough – no more subsidies?
A key problem for the industry is it is wrapped up in red tape. Regulation has been piled upon regulation for decades, and sensible industry-led reform is stymied by the dead hand of government bureaucracy, the result of sweetheart deals with successive insider lobbyists over years.
A Grattan Institute report released last week argues that what is needed is a fresh start. All industry partners need to come together, admit there is a problem, and work together to fix it. The rorts have to end, the barriers to efficiency dismantled, and excess fees reined in.
All industry partners – private health insurers, private hospitals, device importers and manufacturers, and private specialists – have to realise that they need to share in the future, and that a better functioning market will help them all.
The industry needs to ‘own’ its problems, improve its product, develop a plan which addresses the problems which cause contributors to drop out. This will mean fewer nasty bill shocks, and lower premiums driven by more efficient services.
Government needs to say ‘no’ to industry whingeing and demands for more subsidies. But government needs to step up as well, to lead the industry plan and secure the industry’s future by bringing all the partners to the table.
The warning signs could not be clearer: unless private health reforms itself, it may well end up on the automobile scrapheap.
Declaration: Grattan Institute receives funding from corporates, foundations and individuals to support its general activities, including Medibank.
See Croakey’s previous stories on private health insurance.
Support our public interest journalism, for health.
Other ways to support.