The spread of misinformation and disinformation – by media organisations, corporations, digital platforms, politicians, conspiracy theorists and others – is a massive threat to planetary and public health that we have spectacularly failed to address.
The collective “we” includes the international agencies, governments, regulators, civil society organisations, communities, researchers, practitioners, citizens, businesses and others with a stake in this issue – which is pretty well everyone.
The news that Fox will pay $US787.5 million ($1.17 billion) to Dominion Voting Systems – “one of the largest libel payouts in media history” – to settle a defamation suit arising from its broadcasting of false information in the wake of the 2020 United States election does little to prevent or address the wider problems.
A report in The Guardian suggests that the case reflects the limits of using defamation as a tool to police misinformation, and is unlikely to change anything at Fox.
That said, Fox still faces another billion-dollar defamation lawsuit from Smartmatic, another voting equipment company, as well as a shareholder lawsuit seeking damages for spreading false claims, as well as a suit from a former employee who says she was coerced into giving misleading testimony in the Dominion suit.
In many ways the case reminds us that the wealthy and powerful are often involved in the spread of disinformation and misinformation, which no doubt is one of the reasons for our collective failure in addressing it.
Sprinkled through this column are examples of the pervasiveness of misinformation and disinformation, and the many different contexts in which it occurs, highlighting some of the challenges involved in addressing it.
The Voice
See the register of disinformation being spread about the Voice referendum.
Justice
Punitive laws and policing, as highlighted at the Harm Reduction International conference this week, are so often based not on evidence but upon misinformation and disinformation. This is just one of many examples of how misinformation and disinformation undermine human rights.
COVID
This article discusses the spread of misinformation on lockdowns and other public health measures, which the authors refer to as “lock-down revisionism,” and how this phenomenon has damaged trust in public health initiatives designed to keep people safer.
Read the study, Association of COVID-19 Infection With Incident Diabetes
Read the article on long COVID
Read the article on COVID and risk
Read: How a rural school teacher became a top COVID sleuth
Environmental health
Australia (finally) has an Electric Vehicle Strategy.
Media matters
This article includes suggestions for how the media can improve its reporting on COVID, including being “vigilant around our unconscious biases that frame some lives as worth saving while others are not”.
The author writes:
More stories need to include voices and perspectives of people from communities that are most at risk from an infection, such as people from the disabled community, from low-income communities, people of color, and elderly people.
And their perspectives should be included broadly — not just in stories specifically about their communities. We also need to take a step back and look at who we are including. [Dr Lucky] Tran notes that the media relies heavily on quoting medical doctors, for example, who are often not trained in public health.”
See the new WHO guidelines
This analysis suggests improvements in how the media is covering climate science.
The Global Investigative Journalism Network has assembled many useful resources to help journalists do a better job of covering extractive industries. These may also be useful for community groups and environmental and health advocates.
Read the new report on trust in news.
Read the article about Twitter undermining human rights.
Global health
Read The Nature paper on suicide prevention
Read the tribute to Dr Chowdhury
Healthcare rights
Read the article on regional reproductive healthcare
Research and related
Read the article, University ethics boards are not ready for Indigenous scholars
Read the article, Indigenising our universities
Read the article, Critical Tiriti Analysis: A prospective policy making tool from Aotearoa New Zealand
#CroakeyREAD
Events coming up