Related Articles


  1. 1


    I would like a copy of the article!

  2. 2

    Gavin Mooney

    Thanks Simon for bringing this obscenity to our attention. I find it disgusting. I gather the surgeon involved is Charlie Teo – described in the West Australian today (and they did name him) as ‘acclaimed brain surgeon’. I think it is important he is named.

    I am also amazed that no doctors have seemingly responded to your piece. Is this OK with them? Is it OK with the AMA? Respect for the medical profession matters. Would some doctors please respond critically and help to restore my faith in this once noble profession?

  3. 3


    How much money it raises and what the cause might be is irrelelevant. I think the question “is it ethical” should have been asked of the ethics committee of the hospital where Charlie intends to carry out the procedure. If it has and they approved it – I say the proper process has taken place. If it hasn’t and wont see the inside of an ethics committee meeting …….well that is a concern for all health care consumers!

  4. 4
    Melissa Sweet

    Melissa Sweet

    Hi Gavin

    Just to let you know I have received an email from one doctor, who didn’t want to be identified, but who wrote: “…it would be lovely if you could point out that at least one
    member of the medical profession is deeply disturbed by this, and that they wonder whether the surgical team provides a support person for the observer, or whether they assume that the anaesthetist and nurses will be more than happy to explain sensitive medical details, provide a shoulder to lean on and a glass of water if the observer gets woozy, and are completely happy to do their jobs with a layperson in the

    Just to add to that: my own view is that this issue merits a response from beyond the medical profession and bioethicists. What about the fund-raising organisation that was involved; what about the hospital or hospitals where these operations take place?

    And as Chapman’s BMJ article alludes to, what about journalists, documentary makers and others who ask doctors/surgeons and others to ask patients for access to their private and vulnerable moments? (as someone who has done this in the past and will no doubt do it again)

    These broader conversations are useful ones to have, beyond this particular case.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

© 2015 – 2021 Croakey | Website: Rock Lily Design


Follow Croakey