Introduction by Croakey: The Senate is expected to pass the Vaping Reforms Bill 2024 in coming days, bringing an end to all vape sales from general retailers.
With last minute amendments negotiated by the Greens, instead of the prescription-model that was widely supported by the public health community, a person who wishes to use an e-cigarette for therapeutic purposes will be able to purchase only from a pharmacy, from 1 October 2024.
Minister for Health and Aged Care Mark Butler said at a press conference that from 1 July 2024, a prescription from a medical practitioner to obtain e-cigarettes from a pharmacy will be required, but only for a three-month period “to ensure that pharmacists have access to the best possible advice about the way in which to deal with these new laws”.
Mixed views have been expressed to the “watered down” bill.
While the Pharmacy Guild of Australia “strongly opposes” the proposal, Cancer Council Australia, Lung Foundation Australia and the Public Health Association of Australia said in a joint statement: “the legislation presented to Parliament today is essential to stopping vapes ending up in the hands of children and young Australians who have never smoked”.
“This bill may not be perfect, but we cannot wait for perfect,” said CEO of the PHAA, Adjunct Professor Terry Slevin. “The status quo free for all vape market is a disaster for the health of Australians. Every day we delay, more young Australians go down the path of nicotine addiction.”
Below, in an article first published at The Conversation, Associate Professor Becky Freeman, School of Public Health, University of Sydney, says “it’s disappointing the prescription requirement is being removed. This weakens control of a highly addictive and unsafe product”.
Croakey will publish more about this legislation in the coming days.
Becky Freeman writes:
The Australian Senate is set to pass a bill that will see the end of all vape sales – regardless of nicotine content – from general retailers. From July 1, non-nicotine vapes will no longer be permitted for sale outside of pharmacies.
But late amendments to the bill, negotiated by the Greens, change how people will be able to access vapes in the future. When the bill is passed – and for the first three months – people will need a prescription from a medical practitioner to access vapes from their local pharmacy.
Then, from 1 October, 2024, people who wish to use a vape for therapeutic purposes will no longer require a prescription. Instead, they will be able to directly purchase a vape from a pharmacy. Vaping products will be kept behind the counter and only available for purchase with identification to show users are aged over 18.
Vapes sold in pharmacies will be subject to quality and product standards including plain packaging, maximum nicotine concentration levels, and will continue to only be available in mint/menthol and tobacco favours.
It’s disappointing the prescription requirement is being removed. This weakens control of a highly addictive and unsafe product.
The bill had wide support from the public health sector and was based on evidence and research showing that preventing easy access to vapes is essential to protecting the health of young people.
At the same time, the amended bill is a clear improvement on the current situation, where vapes retailers have saturated communities, including near schools.
Still, this uniquely Australian approach to regulating vaping is a world first. The clear message is that vaping products cannot be sold as a consumer good for recreational purposes. Instead, they are a tightly regulated therapeutic product available only under strict conditions.
The law does not criminalise individual vape users, but instead includes heavy penalties for sellers of illegal vapes. Any retailer found to be illegally selling vapes from July 1 will be heavily fined and could face jail time.
Haven’t vape laws already changed?
Vape reform has already been underway. Since March 2024, the federal government has prohibited the importation of all non-therapeutic vapes into Australia.
People wanting to use nicotine vapes (either to quit smoking or for nicotine addiction) have been able to access therapeutic vapes through pharmacies, with a prescription from a health-care professional, in tobacco or mint/menthol flavours.
However, the retail sale of all “non-nicotine” flavoured vapes has remained legal. This has meant petrol stations, convenience stores and vape shops could simply claim they sold “non-nicotine” vapes.
This longstanding loophole in vaping regulation has enabled teens easy access to inexpensive, flavoured, disposable vapes with high nicotine concentrations. Enforcement of this distinction between nicotine and non-nicotine vapes requires extensive and expensive lab testing and proved to be unworkable.
The loophole has fuelled the dramatic rise in young people vaping. In 2019, only 9.6 percent of people aged 14–17 in Australia had ever used vapes. This nearly tripled by 2022–23, to 28 percent.
It has also meant the proliferation of shops openly selling illegal vaping products all across Australia. The large amount of vaping products brought into Australia before the importation regulations were implemented means these illegal sales could could continue for years.
What next?
Some proponents of vaping have argued that all vapes, including those with nicotine, should be sold “just like tobacco products”.
However, the amended bill has not bowed to this industry pressure. Vapes that contain nicotine have never actually been legal to sell as “consumer goods” in general retail shops such as convenience stores, petrol stations and tobacconists. Nicotine is classified as a scheduled poison, which means manufacturers can’t simply add nicotine to consumer products such as sweets, soft drinks or mints, and then sell them in shops.
Making vapes available as a consumer good would be a wholesale change in how Australia regulates dangerous and addictive poisons such as nicotine.
Despite the heralded success of tobacco control, smoking still kills 20,500 Australians every year. Imagine if, in the 1950s when research confirmed smoking was both deadly and addictive, regulators had decided instead to pull the product from the shelves?
We now have an opportunity to prevent a whole new generation from becoming addicted to nicotine. Going forward, it’s crucial the amended legislation is paired with effective monitoring and enforcement to ensure it protects young people.
About the author
Becky Freeman is an Expert Advisor to the Cancer Council Tobacco Issues Committee and a member of the Cancer Institute Vaping Communications Advisory Panel. These are unpaid roles.
She has received relevant competitive grants that include a focus on e-cigarettes/vaping from the NHMRC, MRFF, NSW Health, the Ian Potter Foundation, VicHealth, and Healthway WA; relevant research contracts from the Cancer Institute NSW and the Cancer Council NSW; relevant personal/consulting fees from the World Health Organization, the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Department of Health, BMJ Tobacco Control, the Heart Foundation NSW, the US FDA, the NHMRC e-cigarette working committee, NSW Health, and Cancer Council NSW; and relevant travel expenses from the Oceania Tobacco Control Conference and the Australia Public Health Association preventive health conference.
See Croakey’s archive of articles on vaping and tobacco control
