Introduction: As you read the article below, think about all the community, health and social services that scrape by on insecure and inadequate funding, as well as the under-funded charities across Australia that rely upon volunteers to provide important services to communities.
Think about the ongoing failure of governments to invest adequately in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples’ health and wellbeing, climate justice, in prevention, equitable access to primary healthcare including oral healthcare, and the wellbeing of people on JobSeeker and Youth Allowance, to name just some areas where inadequate funding results in enormous suffering and losses.
Meanwhile, the Pharmacy Guild of Australia – described by a former adviser to Health Ministers, Terry Barnes, as “the most powerful and effective lobby group in the country” – has secured a 22 percent increase in funding under their latest agreement with the Federal Government, compared with their last one.
“No other part of the healthcare system has seen that level of increase in funding support,” writes Adjunct Associate Professor Lesley Russell below. “Such exceptionalism should demand greater transparency, accountability and scrutiny of the influence of the Pharmacy Guild of Australia on government policies.”
This article was first published by The Conversation under the headline, ‘A new Community Pharmacy Agreement starts next month. Here’s what you need to know’.
Lesley Russell writes:
The Albanese Government and the Pharmacy Guild of Australia have this week signed the eighth Community Pharmacy Agreement, which will come into effect on July 1.
The Government has touted the agreement as enabling people to continue to receive cheaper medicines and world-class healthcare from their local pharmacies.
There’s no question pharmacists are integral to delivering healthcare in the community. They are responsible for ensuring prescriptions are filled accurately and in a timely fashion, and for providing advice and guidance to their customers about the medicines they dispense.
But, once again, this agreement shows the power the Pharmacy Guild of Australia, which represents the owners of community pharmacies, wields in shaping policy and funding.
What’s in the agreement?
The Community Pharmacy Agreement was started in 1990 and is renegotiated every five years.
This eighth agreement delivers A$26.5 billion in funding over five years, a $3 billion boost over the previous agreement. This represents about one-quarter of the total cost of the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS).
Of the $26.5 billion, $22.5 billion is for the cost of dispensing prescriptions. The funding also includes $2.1 billion for a new Additional Community Supply Support Payment to address the Pharmacy Guild’s concern about the financial impact of 60-day prescribing.
There’s $1.2 billion to cover pharmacy services, including continuation and expansion of medication management and medical review programs.
This $1.2 billion also includes an increased Regional Pharmacy Maintenance Allowance, which aims to support access to PBS medicines and pharmacy services for people in rural areas. The program provides financial support to eligible pharmacy owners in regional, rural and remote settings. The new agreement increases funding for this allowance by $52 million. Some of the most remote pharmacies may be eligible to receive up to $95,000 per year in support.
Further, $484.4 million will cover the costs of a one-year freeze on the maximum PBS co-payment for everyone with a Medicare card and up to a five-year freeze for pensioners and other Commonwealth concession cardholders. These changes were announced in the recent federal budget.
These changes will require legislation for their enactment. When introduced, the bill should have further details of how this $484.4 million is distributed in costs to government and funding to pharmacies.
Power talks
The Pharmacy Guild of Australia is recognised as a powerful lobbying organisation.
It’s interesting that pharmacy business owners and not pharmacy professional groups are the key drivers of government policy. Indeed, one analysis has characterised the Community Pharmacy Agreements as industry policy benefiting pharmacy owners rather than health policy.
This latest agreement exemplifies the fact that the Pharmacy Guild usually gets what it wants. Last year the Albanese Government announced the 60-day dispensing policy, which doubled the amount of medicine dispensed with some scripts from a 30-day to a 60-day supply. The Pharmacy Guild launched an emotional attack, claiming huge pharmacy losses would result.
The Government subsequently offered an early renegotiation of the Community Pharmacy Agreement (not due until 2025). The Guild eagerly accepted this offer.
In March, Health Minister Mark Butler announced an agreement had been reached between the Government and the Pharmacy Guild. The next Community Pharmacy Agreement would contain an extra $3 billion in pharmacy funding.
This extra funding includes the $2.1 billion, via the new Additional Community Supply Support Payment, to offset presumed pharmacy losses. Pharmacists will receive an extra $4.80, on top of the usual $8.37 dispensing fee and a $4.62 handling fee, when they give out a 60-day script.
Plus there’s the guarantee, in place since 2020, that remuneration per script will increase year on year over the life of the Community Pharmacy Agreement.
Are the agreements effective?
A number of reports have been critical of the lack of data about the effectiveness of the community pharmacy programs supported by the Community Pharmacy Agreements.
A post-implementation review of the seventh agreement found that, in common with previous agreements, there was a lack of effective evaluation and assessment mechanisms for programs. The review said the scarcity and quality of available data for robust and meaningful analysis of health outcomes was a continuing concern.
The Government’s Medical Services Advisory Committee made similar findings about the sixth agreement.
Yet several of these medication management and review programs (for example, Dose Administration Aids, MedsCheck and Diabetes MedsCheck) continue to be funded with a 30 percent increase in this Community Pharmacy Agreement.
Discussion about other programs (for example, Home Medicines Review and Residential Medication Management Review) is continuing as part of the focus on “new and improved pharmacy programs”, allocated $103.3 million in the agreement.
The Pharmacy Guild says it has secured a 22 percent increase in funding under this agreement compared to the last one. No other part of the health-care system has seen that level of increase in funding support.
Such exceptionalism should demand greater transparency, accountability and scrutiny of the influence of the Pharmacy Guild of Australia on government policies.
• Lesley Russell is Adjunct Associate Professor, Menzies Centre for Health Policy and Economics, University of Sydney. She is a member of Croakey Health Media, and a contributing editor, and author of the regular column, The Health Wrap. She previously worked as a health policy staffer for the federal Australian Labor Party, and as a Senior Advisor to the United States Surgeon General in the Department of Health and Human Services.
See Croakey’s coverage of pharmacy-related issues
