Some extremely interesting conversations must have been occurring behind closed doors in pharmacy-land, in the wake of the disastrous deal between the Pharmacy Guild and Blackmores.
According to a Guild statement reproduced in full below, the deal – for pharmacists’ computer systems to prompt them to discuss Blackmores products with patients picking up a prescription for certain medications – will not go ahead in response “to the strong level of public concern”.
However, the statement also attacks some media reporting of the arrangement as “ill-informed and inflammatory” (I thought rule one of crisis management 101 was to say sorry – and to mean it – rather than to continue attacking your critics…)
As has been widely reported, the plan drew no end of criticisms. Policy heavyweight Andrew Podger suggested the Guild was “hopefully kicking a monumental own goal” in its ongoing efforts to resist greater competition in the industry.
Personally, I thought the reported comments of Blackmores CEO, Christine Holgate, said everything. She told Pharmacy News that the arrangement gave Blackmores the opportunity to provide the “coke and fries” for these pharmaceutical medicines, while “also providing a new and important revenue stream for community pharmacy”.
What a peculiar comparison, to put it mildly.
A statement from the Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists and Managers is also published below, and includes this punch: “Australian pharmacists should never forget that the Guild was willing to trade on the good reputation of pharmacists for commercial gain.”
For more reaction, see The Science-Based Pharmacy blog.
No doubt the fall-out will continue, in one form or another…
The Guild statement
5 October 2011
Gold Cross endorsement of Blackmores Companions range withdrawn
The Pharmacy Guild of Australia and Blackmores have agreed that the Gold Cross endorsement of the Blackmores Companions range of complementary medicines will be withdrawn.
The mutual decision has been taken in view of the strong level of public concern about the proposal, based on some media reporting of the endorsement which was ill-informed and inflammatory.
The last thing the Guild would ever want to do is deplete the credibility of community pharmacists, or damage the trust in which they are held by Australians. That trust and confidence is of paramount importance to the Guild and to our Members.
The Gold Cross endorsement arrangement with Blackmores was entered in good faith, with absolutely no intention of undermining the professionalism and integrity of participating pharmacists. There is not now and never would be any direction from the Guild for pharmacists to be involved in unprofessional, unethical or clinically unsound conduct. The idea that community pharmacists would take part in commercial “upselling” without regard to their professional standards is offensive to our profession and rejected by the Guild.
However, perceptions are very important, and it is overwhelmingly clear that the public perception of this endorsement was damaging to the reputation of community pharmacy. Both the public, and sections of the broader pharmacy industry expressed strong concerns about the proposal.
The Guild has listened to these concerns and accepts – mutually with Blackmores – that the best course in all the circumstances is to withdraw the endorsement arrangement. The Guild regrets any damage done to the image of community pharmacy and will do everything possible to ensure the public maintain their trust in community pharmacists as the custodians of medicines and the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme.
The National President of the Guild, Kos Sclavos, said: “We entered this arrangement in good faith, but we have now agreed with Blackmores that the furore that has been created is doing damage, and must be dealt
with before it further damages community pharmacists and the patients they serve. The only alternative is to cancel the endorsement, and this has been done. I add my personal apologies for any distress this has caused to pharmacists.”
Gold Cross, a fully owned subsidiary of the Guild, had agreed to endorse a range of Blackmores products, which meant that the range of four Companions products would have the Guild’s Gold Cross on their packaging.
Additionally, an optional prompt containing clinical information for the patient to consider in relation to one product of the Companions range was to be available through the dispensary IT programs, on a pilot basis. The software pilot was not intended to commence until at least November, and will now not proceed.
Blackmores products are well-established, and marketed by one of the best known and respected names in evidence-based complementary medicine. Many doctors, pharmacists and other health professionals make recommendations for these types of products frequently.
Blackmores developed this range of four to be available exclusively through pharmacies so that consumers would always obtain the appropriate information and advice.
Contrary to some media reports, there was never any compulsion whatsoever on pharmacists to sell these products, nor was there any direct incentive to any pharmacist to sell them. At all times, community pharmacists would continue to be free – and indeed expected – to exercise their professional and clinical judgement in relation to these products.
Media inquiries: Greg Turnbull 0412 910 261
APESMA WINS – GUILD AND BLACKMORES DUMP ‘COKE AND FRIES’ DEAL
Pharmacists around Australia will be rejoicing today after the Pharmacy owners Guild and Blackmores Ltd announced they would not be going ahead with their deal to get more pharmacists to upsell Blackmores products.
CEO of APESMA Chris Walton said the announcement followed a strong campaign from APESMA and the rest of the Pharmacist Coalition for Health Reform.
However he warned that pharmacists should continue to be wary of the Pharmacy owners Guild now that their hunger for profits had been exposed by the fiasco.
“This is a pathetic back down by an out of touch organisation,” Mr Walton said.
“The Pharmacy owners Guild has been dragged kicking and screaming to the decision and still will not take responsibility. They describe their decision to enter the deal as one made in good faith. Good faith must be their code for a big bag of coin.
“Australian pharmacists should never forget that the Guild was willing to trade on the good reputation of pharmacists for commercial gain.
“While the same people are in charge why would we ever trust them ever again? Any pretence that they represent the pharmacy profession is over.”
Mr Walton thanked pharmacist members of APESMA for their support during the campaign and called on other pharmacists to join up today and continue to stand up for a better future for the pharmacy profession.
“We should remember that when pharmacists work with groups like APESMA and the Pharmacist Coalition for Health Reform we can change the Guild’s mind and we can stand up for professional pharmacists,” Mr Walton said.
The Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists and Managers, Australia (APESMA) is the largest national non-profit organisation representing professional employees including engineers, scientists, managers, architects, IT professionals, pharmacists, surveyors, veterinarians, collieries staff and many other professionals. Our 25,000+ members are found in all areas of public and private employment across Australia.
For more information contact Matt Nurse, APESMA Media and Marketing Manager on 0407 351 277