Introduction by Croakey: Since it was established in 1988, World No Tobacco Day has provided a platform for highlighting the wide-ranging impacts of the tobacco industry, as examined in two articles below.
In the first article, Alison Barrett reports on related developments, globally and locally, including the launch yesterday of iSISTAQUIT videos to support Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander women in quitting smoking.
The second article, by Sam Filby, research officer at the University of Cape Town, is cross-published from The Conversation Africa, and investigates how the industry is driving increasing rates of smoking in some African countries, and discusses some solutions.
Poisoning our planet
Alison Barrett writes:
World No Tobacco Day has highlighted the insidious influence of the global tobacco industry, not just directly on individual and population health but on the environment and institutional governance.
A World Health Organization (WHO) report released last week – ‘Tobacco: Poisoning our planet‘ – documents the environmental consequences of tobacco production, consumption, waste and cultivation.
“Tobacco products are the most littered item on the planet, containing over 7,000 toxic chemicals, which leech into our environment when discarded,” said Dr Ruediger Krech, Director of Health Promotion at WHO, in a statement.
“Roughly 4.5 trillion cigarette filters pollute our oceans, rivers, city sidewalks, parks, soil and beaches every year.”
In the United States, lobbying of the Federal Government by corporate groups, including tobacco-affiliated organisations, has been linked to actions to “restrict funding to, censure, and undermine confidence in the WHO”, according to a recent comprehensive analysis of lobbying expenditures.
The analysis found examples of tobacco-affiliated lobbying to reduce US funding for WHO by 25 percent and opposition to plain packaging on tobacco products.
While global rates of smoking have decreased over the past decade, tobacco use still poses a financial, social and health burden worldwide.
World No Tobacco Day also brings an opportunity to spotlight success in tobacco control efforts.
In a positive example of a culturally safe quit smoking campaign, iSISTAQUIT launched a series of videos yesterday, designed to support culturally safe and evidence-based care for Aboriginal and Torres Strait women.
Donnella Mills, Chair of NACCHO and Chair of the Wuchopperan Health Service in Cairns, told the launch that she encourages all Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services to register and complete the iSISTAQUIT training.
iSISTAQUIT provides support for pregnant Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander women who are wanting to quit smoking, as well as training for health professionals.
Watch Nova Peris addressing the launch, and see the iSISTAQUIT videos here. (See more tweets at the end of this post).
African countries need tighter controls to curb growing tobacco use
Sam Filby writes:
Average global smoking rates have fallen over the past 12 years with the proportion of people aged 15 or older who smoke declining from 22.6 percent in 2007 to 19.6 percent in 2019.
However, tobacco use still poses a significant health, economic and social burden worldwide. In fact, some countries – mostly in Africa – are experiencing increases in smoking prevalence. The latest Tobacco Atlas shows that, globally, 1.13 billion people were current smokers in 2019. And 8.67 million deaths were attributable to tobacco smoking.
The Tobacco Atlas – a partnership between Vital Strategies and Tobacconomics at the University of Illinois Chicago – is a free online resource that examines the nature and magnitude of the tobacco epidemic.
Tobacco use also presents a sizeable economic burden. This includes the cost of treating tobacco-related diseases such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and ischaemic heart disease, as well as the productivity losses from premature illness and death. Globally, the total economic cost of smoking amounts to more than US$ 1.4 trillion a year – equal to about 1.8 percent of the world’s annual gross domestic product (GDP).
Africa currently has the lowest smoking prevalence rates in the world. But number of smokers in Africa is projected to increase – the region has been flagged as the future epicentre of the tobacco epidemic because of rapid population growth, and intensive marketing efforts by the tobacco industry.
Because of the delay between smoking and the onset of illness and death, this means that the number of African people who will die each year from tobacco-related diseases is likely to increase. The costs of treating smoking-related diseases will correspondingly become an increasingly significant economic burden in these countries.
It is, however, possible to avert this. Key steps include introducing strong prevention policies.
Curbing tobacco use
Tobacco kills half of its long-term users. Hence, the tobacco industry’s survival depends on getting young people addicted to tobacco products. Traditional advertising and promotion of tobacco products has been banned in most African countries. But the tobacco industry has developed novel ways of keeping its products in the public eye.
In Zimbabwe, for example, China Tobacco set up the China Tobacco Ma Bo Hope Primary School in 2019. In this way, the industry is using corporate social responsibility to gain legitimacy, build public trust, and further its business interests. From building schools to funding scholarships, tobacco companies use these publicised acts of goodwill to gain influence with governments and try to mute life-saving tobacco control policies.
One way for governments to fight back is through the use of counter-advertising campaigns that educate young people about the tactics the industry uses to target them. This can be done through mass marketing campaigns on the harms of tobacco use and through the introduction of plain packaging and graphic health warnings on tobacco packs.
These tools are under-used in Africa. Between 2018 and 2020, only 15 African countries ran at least one mass media campaign about the harms of tobacco use. And not a single African country has laws that mandate plain packaging.
Taxation is another possible line of attack. Research shows that tobacco taxation is effective in reducing smoking, especially among young people.
This is particularly true for young people in low to middle income countries. Global-level studies show that young people in these countries are more responsive to cigarette price changes than their counterparts in high-income countries.
The policy implication for African countries is that excise taxes should be increased to reduce smoking among young people. This would go a long way to preventing the onset of the epidemic.
But, as, the Tobacco Atlas highlights, African countries have the weakest tobacco excise tax policies in the world.
Exercising control
Tobacco control policy can be used in two ways:
- to discourage people from ever starting to smoke
- to help smokers quit or reduce their tobacco consumption.
The recommended policies for both prevention and cessation strategies are similar (increasing tobacco taxes). But their cost-effectiveness is different.
The most important benefit of prevention is that costs of smoking are avoided altogether, and better health is good for economic performance immediately. The benefits of cessation are essentially the reduction in costs attached to current and future tobacco use.
African governments need to see this distinction. Policy makers in the region don’t appear to appreciate the opportunity they have to save their populations and economies from the negative consequences of tobacco use. The time to act is now.
About the author and disclosure statement
Sam Filby is the project manager of the Knowledge Hub and a research officer at the Research Unit on the Economics of Excisable Products (REEP). She is also a lecturer and course convenor in the School of Economics at the University of Cape Town. Her salary is derived from funding from the African Capacity Building Foundation, which is in turn funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, Cancer Research UK and the CDC Foundation.
From Twitter
Read Twitter thread by the Public Health Association of Australia on their World No Tobacco Day event here.
Further reading
Read more about iSISTAQUIT here.
Read the full analysis on corporate lobbying here (from page 37).
Read the World Health Organization report, ‘Tobacco: poisoning our planet’ here.
See Croakey’s archive of stories on tobacco control.
